Hall of Shame Nominee: Doctor Who
(By: Dara Antonelli and Erika Bell)
Element 1: Nobility and Virtue
Element 2: The Character is Relatable
Element 3: The Character is Flawed, and their Flaw is their Downfall
His downfall would most likely be when he killed the rest of his race during the last great time war between the time lords and the daleks. However, at the time, he felt his actions were ethically just because while he may have been killing the last of his race, he was also killing the daleks and ending the war. (Later on it reveals more about how he may have saved the time lords rather than killed them, but that's all wibbly wobbly timey wimey stuff)
"If I could go back and save Gallifrey, then I would, but I couldn't. I could never go back"
-The 10th Doctor, Fires of Pompeii
Element 4: The Punishment Exceeds the Crime
Element 5: The Character Has a Discovery
Element 6: Doesn't Leave the Audience Depressed
Sources:
http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Last_Great_Time_War
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1279348-time-lord-victorious
http://fyeahtimelordvictorious.tumblr.com/
(Also, our prior knowledge and Erika's previously saved photos/gifs)