Macbeth Act 5 Scene 1
1971 Roman Polanski vs. 2010 Rupert Goold
Witch one of these 2 versions were closer to the text of the book.
Theses Versions compare to the text of the book because they both have the same tone as the book. They also compare to the book because they keep the same words as the book instead of putting it in there own words. The version that was the most accurate to the book was the 1971 Roman Polanski version. This version was the closest to the book because it had the same tone and setting and characterization as the book. The film that I liked better was 2010 Rupert Goold version because it gave me a better understanding and it caught more of my attention and it was more intense then the other film.
Macbeth Polanski 1971 pt.14 Lady Sonâmbula (português).avi
레이디 맥베스
similarity of 1971 Roman Pulanski and 2010 Rupert Goold
One thing that these two versions have in common is that Lady Macbeth is acting crazy like she has completely lost her mind. It was significant because it was like the book but only I picture mutation which made it better.
Difference of 1971 Roman Pulanski and 2010 Rupert Goold
One Difference in this two version is that in Roman Pulanski version is that Lady Macbeth is naked and doesn't cry as much as Lady Macbeth in Rupert Goold version and also in Rupert Goold version Lady Macbeth is clothed and acts more crazy.
Difference of 1971 Roman Pulanski and 2010 Rupert Goold
Another Difference I noticed was that in Roman Polanski version is that Lady Macbeth was in here bedroom and in Rupert Goold version Lady Macbeth was in a dark hall. In Rupert Goold version Lady Macbeth acts more crazy then Lady Macbeth in Roman Polanskis version.