Gibbons Vs. Ogden's
Gibbons v. Ogden (1824) Wickard v. Filburn (1942) Hammer v. Dagenhart (1918)
Hammer v. Dagenhart (1918)
As for the 5th and 10th amendment it made a clear statement allowing certain rules to be specifically incorporated in our daily lives. As for Roland Dagenhart he followed these 2 amendments but has the opinions of many explaining to the judge that he is wrong for having his 2 teenage sons working in his factory for long hours. Going by the law he's done nothing wrong according to what the 10 amendments are. The child labor law states if the child's surroundings are unsafe and unhealthy including the fact that they're under age then that is when it's considered against the law. With the fact that his teenage sons weren't under age it gave another reason as to why it wasn't wrong to have his own sons there. Dagenhart's children not attending school so often gave W.C Hammer who was an appellant adding a statement which was according to the Child Labor Law children must go to school up to a certain age, in which his children weren't so this was put against Roland. As for many other opinions including mines I believe even though his children were in good conditions it still gives no reason to keep your own children out of school. Congress doesn't have to much power over this all because they don't have the right to regulate the manufacture goods simply because the goods might be shipped in interstate commerce. With all of this happening it's harder to put something against Dagenhart from whats hes doing.
Thomas Gibbons
Gibbons stated that New York manage the same power as interstate.
Aaron ogdens
Licensed steamboat basically allowed to operate.
Supreme court
Still undecided with this until the state prevents similar laws.
Agriculture Adjustment Act 1938
Agriculture adjustment act put limits towards farmers in wheat production.
Penalties for over production.
Benefits the market by stabilizing the economy and wheat production including over farmer productions.
Roscoe Filburn
Believes he should have some for himself.
He over did the limit of wheat he produced.
Court opinion
Self supply would highly affect commerce within the state.
Agriculture adjustment act put limits towards farmers in wheat production.
William. C. Hammer
Appellant { Applied to a higher court to have a better decision then the lower court.
Stated that you shouldn't ignore the Child Labor law, putting your young children to work those hours were too much and wrong.
Roland Dagenhart
Tenth Amendment gave the right for child labor.
Fifth Amendment protection of property and liberty allow his children to do so.
Child Labor law
Banned interstate commerce especially when it comes to employed children under the age of 14.