The Tempest

Mixed Feelings

Discussion Questions

What does Alonso think happened to Ferdinand?

Alonso thinks that Ferdinand drowned.


Why isn't Prospero going to kill Alonso?

He isn't going to kill Alonso because he wants him to punish him worse than killing him

"Do pronounce by me lingering perdition, worse than any death can be at once," (Shakespeare 27).


Why does Ariel confront Alonso, Antonio, and Sebastian?

"ARIEL

(to ALONSO, ANTONIO, and SEBASTIAN )

You are three men of sin, whom Destiny,

That hath to instrument this lower world

And what is in ’t, the never-surfeited sea

Hath caused to belch up you—and on this island

Where man doth not inhabit, you ’mongst men

Being most unfit to live. I have made you mad,

And even with suchlike valor men hang and drown

Their proper selves. (some of the courtiers draw their swords)

You fools, I and my fellows

Are ministers of fate. The elements

Of whom your swords are tempered may as well

Wound the loud winds or with bemocked-at stabs

Kill the still-closing waters as diminish

One dowl that’s in my plume. My fellow ministers

Are like invulnerable. If you could hurt,

Your swords are now too massy for your strengths

And will not be uplifted. But remember—

For that’s my business to you—that you three

From Milan did supplant good Prospero,

Exposed unto the sea, which hath requit it,

Him and his innocent child. For which foul deed

The powers—delaying, not forgetting—have

Incensed the seas and shores, yea, all the creatures,

Against your peace.—Thee of thy son, Alonso,

They have bereft, and do pronounce by me

Lingering perdition, worse than any death

Can be at once, shall step by step attend

You and your ways; whose wraths to guard you from—

Which here, in this most desolate isle, else falls

Upon your heads—is nothing but hearts' sorrow

And a clear life ensuing." (Shakespeare 27)


ARIEL

(to ALONSO, ANTONIO, and SEBASTIAN) The three of you are sinners, and Destiny made the sea belch you up onto this island—where no men live, since none of you deserve to live. I’ve driven you crazy, and many mad people are driven to kill themselves in desperation.(some of the courtiers draw their swords) Listen, you fools, my fellow

HARPIES

A harpy is a mythological creature with a woman’s face and breasts and the wings and claws of a bird. Shakespeare apparently intended to have Ariel appear together with two other harpies.

harpies and I carry out Fate’s orders. Your swords are useless against us—you’d be more successful swinging them at the empty air, or stabbing at water, than trying to cut off even one of my feathers. My two companions are just as invulnerable as I am. Even if you had the power to hurt us, you’d find your swords far too heavy to lift. But remember—and it’s my job to remind you of this—that in Milan the three of you stole Prospero’s throne and threw him and his innocent child into the sea, which has now taken revenge on you. To punish you for this horrible crime, the higher powers—delaying their punishment, not forgetting about it—have stirred up the seas and all the creatures of earth against you.—They’ve taken your only son from you, Alonso, and they’ve ordered me to destroy you slowly, in a way worse than sudden death could ever be. I’ll stay with you every step of your way. The only way to protect yourselves from the angry higher powers—which are ready to fall upon your head on this empty island—is for you to be sincerely sorry in your hearts for what you’ve done, and to live innocent lives from this time forward.

Character Analysis

Alonso

Hopeless:

"Even here I will put off my hope and keep it no longer for my flatterer." (Shakespeare 26).


Optimistic:

I will stand to and feed,

Although my last. No matter, since I feel

The best is past. Brother, my lord the duke,

Stand to and do as we. (Shakespeare 2?)

Gonzalo:

Aging:

"(to ALONSO) By 'r lakin, I can go no further, sir.

My old bones ache. Here’s a maze trod indeed

Through forthrights and meanders. By your patience,

I needs must rest me." (Shakespeare 26)

Assuring:

"Gonzalo: Faith, sir, you need not fear. When we were boys,

Who would believe that there were mountaineers

Dewlapped like bulls, whose throats had hanging at 'em

Wallets of flesh, or that there were such men

Whose heads stood in their breasts?—which now we find

Each putter-out of five for one will bring us

Good warrant of." (Shakespeare 2?)


Translation: I assure you, sir, there’s nothing to be afraid of. When we were boys, who’d believe that there were mountain people with rolls of skin around their necks, with their throats hanging down? Or that there were men with heads in their chests?—Nowadays travelers commonly report that these things exist.

Antonio:

Impatient, Eager:

"Let it be tonight,

For now they are oppressed with travel. They

Will not, nor cannot, use such vigilance

As when they are fresh." (Shakespeare 2?)

Ariel:

Valorous:

"You fools! I and my fellows are ministers of fate: the elements, of whom your swords are temeper'd, may as well Wound the loud winds,or with bemocke'd-at stabs kill the still-closing waters, as diminish one dowle that's in my plum: my fellow-ministers are like invulnerable."(Shakespeare 27).

Translation:

Prospero:

Happy-

"My high charms work and theses mine enemies are all knit up in their distractions; they now are in my power; and in these fits I leave them " (Shakespeare 27).

Theme

For the them I chose "It is right to manipulate others to get your way of wishes."

I chose this theme for the climax of the play Act 3 scene 3 because in this section Ariel uses soft music, shadows in the sky, and a banquet of food in a attempt to manipulate Gonzalo, Alonso, and Sebastion into apologizing for there sin and to live a innocent life.


The quest for power is worth it, no matter the cost.

"ANTONIO

(aside to SEBASTIAN) I am right glad that he’s so out of hope.

Do not for one repulse forego the purpose

That you resolved t' effect.



SEBASTIAN

(aside to ANTONIO) The next advantage

Will we take throughly.





ANTONIO

(aside to SEBASTIAN) Let it be tonight,

For now they are oppressed with travel. They

Will not, nor cannot, use such vigilance

As when they are fresh." (Shakespeare 26)



Human interaction is needed in order to survive.

"Enter several strange shapes, bringing in a banquet They dance about it with gentle actions of salutations, and, inviting the king and the others to eat, they depart

ALONSO

Give us kind keepers, heavens! What were these?" (Shakespeare 26)

Visualizer

Page 26, 2nd column, in italics

I chose to draw the picture this way because to me this is the most visual part. This is the part when Prospero showed hospitality towards King Alonso, Gonzalo, Sebastian, Antonio and others dinner. I visualized random shapes bringing in dinner and the thought of that was nice. It was nice because Prospero, a man scorned, was bringing dinner for Antonio, including others, which he was planning to seek revenge on.

Director

*CENTER MUST BE CLEAR, PLEASE MOVE!*

I decided to direct the play this way and to have my group act out our entire part of the play because it is the climax of the story. I made it more real by adding sound affects and props.