Macbeth Act 1 Scene1
1971 Roman Polanski vs. 2010 Rupert Goold
Play vs. Movie Scenes
The film versions compare to the novel due to their characters and their script. Roman Polanki's version was more acurate because it's setting was more in shakespeares era. although i watched Rupert Goold's version of the movie, i say that roman polanski's version was better, because it wasn't modern like rupert goold's version where they had guns and looked like WWII.
difference from Roman Polanskis to Rupert Goold
one difference is that in Roman Polanski's version of the movie, the witches seem really old and odd. theirs nothing crazier than a scene where you dont understand what they are doing and you just guess they are crazy. another difference is that the setting takes place in a beach.
Rupert Goold's version to Roman polanski's
one difference is that the witches look more like nurses, and right away they start acting crazy and saying a spell to one another.another difference is that the setting was in a underground hall and not i the beach like in Roman Polanski's version.
similarities in both movies.
in both movies, the witches dont match the actual witches character. because in shakespeare's novel macbeth; the witches are known to have beards, and this is something that bot movies have in commmon. another thing that the movies have in common, is that they match the character's mood. if the mood s acting crazy, then acting crazy it was.